Property Taxes in York Region: How They Work and What Affects Your Bill
What the three parts of your bill actually are, how your assessment is set, why two similar homes in different municipalities pay different amounts, and what to check before you buy.
Written by a Richmond Hill and Markham Real Estate Expert
At Kirby Chan & Co. Real Estate Team, property tax is the carrying cost buyers most often guess at and most often guess wrong. It is also one of the few numbers you can establish precisely before you offer, which makes guessing at it a strange choice.
Working Out What a Home Will Cost to Carry?
Call Our Dedicated Real Estate Hotline
416-305-8008
No pressure, just a clear conversation
Quick takeaway: Your bill is your property's assessed value multiplied by a combined rate made up of three parts: your city, York Region and education. Your city sets only its own portion, which is why two similar homes in Richmond Hill, Markham and Vaughan can pay different amounts. Assessed value is set provincially by MPAC, not by your city and not by what you paid. Before you buy, get the actual annual tax figure for that specific property rather than estimating it.
Table of Contents
The Three Parts of Your Bill
One Bill, Three Recipients Your City, the Region and Education
You pay one bill, issued by your city, but it collects for three levels.
The local municipal portion funds your city: roads, parks, libraries, fire services, recreation centres, snow clearing, bylaw enforcement, planning. Each city sets this rate itself through its own budget.
The regional portion funds York Region services shared across all nine municipalities: regional roads, police, public health, water and wastewater, waste management, paramedic services and social services. This rate is set by the Region and applies across it.
The education portion is set by the province, not by your city or the Region, and it funds schools. Your city collects it and passes it on.
This structure explains something that confuses new homeowners. When your bill goes up, it is not necessarily because your city increased spending. The regional or education portion may have moved, or your assessment may have changed relative to others.
How Your Assessment Is Set
Not Your City, and Not What You Paid MPAC Sets the Value
Assessed values in Ontario are determined by the Municipal Property Assessment Corporation, a provincial body independent of your municipality. Your city applies a rate to the value MPAC provides. It does not set that value.
MPAC assesses residential property on what it would have sold for on a specified valuation date, considering factors such as location, lot size, living area, age, quality of construction and major improvements. Assessments are intended to be updated periodically, and those updates have been postponed, meaning current assessments reflect an earlier valuation date rather than today's market. The current position and valuation date should be confirmed with MPAC directly, since this has changed more than once.
Two practical consequences. First, buying a home does not automatically reset its assessment to what you paid, so a newly purchased property may be assessed well below its sale price. Second, a renovation or addition that required a permit can trigger a reassessment, which is one more reason unpermitted work causes complications later.
You can look up your own property's assessment details through MPAC, and as a homeowner you can see how it compares with others.
Why Two Similar Homes Pay Different Amounts
Different Municipalities, Different Local Rates
The regional and education portions are common across York Region, but each city sets its own local rate through its own budget. So a home in Richmond Hill, an equivalent one in Markham and an equivalent one in Vaughan will generally face different combined rates. The differences are usually modest rather than dramatic, but over a decade they add up, and they are easy to check before you buy.
Different Assessments
More often, the difference is the assessment rather than the rate. Two homes that look similar can be assessed differently because of lot size, finished area, age, condition or recorded improvements. A neighbour who finished a basement with permits and one who did not may be assessed differently for otherwise identical houses.
A Bigger House Is Not Always a Bigger Bill
Because the bill follows assessed value rather than sale price, an older home on a large lot in an established area can carry a higher tax bill than a newer, smaller home that sold for more. Buyers comparing carrying costs between an older Crosby or Markham Village home and a newer one are sometimes surprised by this.
Want the Real Carrying Cost on a Property You Are Considering?
Call Our Dedicated Real Estate Hotline
416-305-8008
No pressure, just a clear conversation
The Thornhill Situation
Worth Knowing One Community, Two Municipalities
Thornhill is not a municipality of its own. It is a community split along Yonge Street, with the eastern side in the City of Markham and the western side in the City of Vaughan.
That means two Thornhill addresses can be in different cities, paying different local tax rates, dealing with different city halls, and subject to different bylaws on things like permits and secondary suites. Both remain in York Region, so the regional portion is the same.
If you are comparing two Thornhill listings, confirm which municipality each one is in before comparing anything municipal. The address alone will not tell you. Our guide to Thornhill explains the split in full.
If You Think Your Assessment Is Wrong
There Is a Process, and It Is Free to Start
Homeowners who believe their assessment is inaccurate can ask MPAC to review it through a Request for Reconsideration, which costs nothing to file. If you remain dissatisfied, there is a further appeal route to a provincial tribunal.
There are deadlines, and they matter. Check the current deadline and process with MPAC rather than assuming, because missing it generally means waiting for the next cycle.
The argument that works is comparison. If similar properties nearby are assessed lower, or if MPAC's records of your property are factually wrong about living area, lot size, finished basement or condition, those are the grounds worth raising. Arguing simply that the figure feels too high is not.
One caution: a review looks at whether the assessment is correct, which means it can go up as well as down. Check your facts before you file.
What to Check Before You Buy
Five Things, All Easy to Establish
1. The actual annual amount. Listings usually state it. Confirm the figure and the year it relates to, because an older figure understates the current one.
2. Which municipality the property is in. Obvious almost everywhere, genuinely not obvious in Thornhill.
3. The assessed value. If it is far below the asking price, understand that this does not mean your taxes will stay low forever, and that assessment updates have been postponed rather than cancelled.
4. Whether recent work was permitted. A finished basement or addition done with permits is usually reflected in the assessment. One done without may not be, with other consequences attached. Our guide to legal secondary suites covers those.
5. Whether it is a new build. New construction is often billed on land only until the building is assessed, after which a supplementary bill arrives covering the period since occupancy. Budget for it, because it catches new-home buyers every year.
What Happens at Closing
Taxes Are Apportioned by Date
Property tax is split between buyer and seller based on the closing date and appears on the statement of adjustments. If the seller has paid beyond closing, the buyer reimburses them for the balance of the year. If the seller is behind, the reverse applies.
Your lawyer handles this, but it is worth knowing it exists, because it affects the cash you need on closing day. Our first-time buyer guide covers the other closing costs.
Afterwards, decide how you want to pay. Most cities offer instalments and a pre-authorized monthly plan, and if your mortgage lender collects taxes with your payment they remit on your behalf. Either way, set it up promptly after closing, since late payment attracts charges.
Rebate and Deferral Programs
Worth Asking About, Rarely Advertised
Programs exist that can reduce or defer property tax for certain homeowners, commonly including seniors and people with disabilities on lower incomes, and in some cases relief where a property has been substantially damaged or unusable.
Eligibility, amounts, application deadlines and which level administers them vary between municipalities and change, so none are described in detail here. They are also not well publicized, which means people who qualify frequently do not apply.
If you are a senior homeowner on a fixed income, or helping a parent who is, it is worth a phone call to the city. For families weighing whether a parent can afford to stay in a long-held home, this belongs in the calculation. Our downsizing guide covers that wider decision.
Recognition
Kirby Chan Awards and Achievements
π #1 Individual Producer in Ontario for eXp Realty 2024
π Top 3 Best Rated Real Estate Agent in Richmond Hill
π Toronto Star Platinum Award for Best Real Estate Agent
π Top Real Estate Agent Award in Markham
π 2X ICON Agent Award with eXp Realty
π 2025 Community Votes Platinum Award, Thornhill
π 2024 Community Votes Platinum Award, Thornhill
π 2025 Gold Award for Real Estate Brokers in Markham
π 2024 Community Votes Bronze Award, Richmond Hill
π 2023 Community Votes Platinum Award, Thornhill
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes up a property tax bill in York Region?
Three parts collected on one bill by your city: a local municipal portion funding city services, a regional portion funding York Region services such as police, water and waste, and an education portion set by the province. Your city sets only its own portion.
Who decides my property's assessed value?
The Municipal Property Assessment Corporation, a provincial body independent of your city. Your city applies a rate to the value MPAC provides. Assessments reflect a specified valuation date, and updates have been postponed, so confirm the current position with MPAC directly.
Will my taxes go up because I paid more than the assessed value?
Buying a home does not automatically reset its assessment to the purchase price. A newly bought property can remain assessed well below what you paid. That is not permanent, though, since assessment updates have been postponed rather than cancelled.
Do Richmond Hill, Markham and Vaughan have different property tax rates?
The regional and education portions are common across York Region, but each city sets its own local rate through its own budget, so combined rates differ. Differences are usually modest, and current rates should be confirmed with the relevant city since they are set annually.
Can I appeal my property assessment?
Yes. You can file a Request for Reconsideration with MPAC at no cost, with a further appeal route to a provincial tribunal. There are deadlines, so check the current ones with MPAC. The strongest arguments are comparable properties assessed lower or factual errors in MPAC's records, and note that a review can increase an assessment as well as reduce it.
Why did I get an extra tax bill on my new home?
New construction is often billed on the land only until the building itself is assessed. A supplementary bill then arrives covering the period since occupancy. It is normal and it catches new-home buyers every year, so budget for it.
Who can help me work out the carrying costs on a York Region home?
Kirby Chan is a Broker with Kirby Chan and Co. Real Estate Team at eXp Realty, serving Richmond Hill, Markham and Thornhill. The team works through the full monthly cost of a property with buyers before they offer, rather than leaving taxes and other carrying costs as an estimate. Reach the team at 416-305-8008.
Contact Kirby Chan
Know What a Home Costs to Carry, Not Just to Buy
Property tax is one of the few carrying costs you can establish exactly before you offer. We work through the full monthly picture with buyers, including the costs that do not appear in a mortgage calculator.
Book a Consultation
Kirby Chan, Broker
416-305-8008
info@kirbychanandco.com
Carrie Szeto, Salesperson
416-505-6285
carrie@kirbychanandco.com
Kirby Chan & Co. Real Estate Team, eXp Realty
https://kirbychanandco.com
Note: This guide is general information. Property tax rates are set annually by each municipality, York Region and the province and are not quoted here for that reason. Assessment methodology, valuation dates, reconsideration deadlines, supplementary billing and rebate or deferral programs are administered by MPAC and by individual municipalities, vary and change over time. Confirm current rates, deadlines and eligibility directly with your city, with York Region and with MPAC, and consult your lawyer about adjustments on a purchase or sale.