Divorce and the Matrimonial Home in Richmond Hill
Divorce and the Matrimonial Home in Richmond Hill and Markham: Understanding Your Options
When a marriage ends, the family home is usually the largest asset and the hardest decision. In Ontario the matrimonial home has a special legal status that surprises most people, including rules about who can stay, who can sell and how its value is counted. This guide explains how that status works, what your options are for the home and what the process looks like practically for separating couples in Richmond Hill and Markham.
Written by a Richmond Hill and Markham Real Estate Expert
At Kirby Chan & Co. Real Estate Team, we work with Richmond Hill and Markham couples who are separating and need to make a decision about the family home. We have seen how much easier the process becomes when both people understand the rules early, rather than discovering halfway through that the home cannot be listed without both signatures. If you are separating in Richmond Hill or Markham, understanding the ground rules first makes every conversation that follows a little calmer.
Quick takeaway: Under Ontario's Family Law Act, the matrimonial home gets treatment no other asset receives. For married spouses, both generally have an equal right to live in it regardless of whose name is on title, and neither can sell or mortgage it without the other's consent or a court order. That means listing the home almost always requires both spouses to agree and to sign. Your realistic options are to sell and divide the proceeds, have one spouse buy out the other, or defer the sale to a later date. Common-law partners are treated very differently under Ontario law. Every situation turns on its own facts, so speak with a family lawyer before making decisions about the home.
Table of Contents
- What Counts as a Matrimonial Home
- Why It Is Treated Differently
- Married and Common-Law Are Not the Same
- Your Three Main Options
- If You Decide to Sell
- Working With an Agent While Separating
- Getting the Right Support
- Frequently Asked Questions
What Counts as a Matrimonial Home
In general terms, a matrimonial home is a property that married spouses ordinarily occupied as their family residence at the time they separated. For most couples in Richmond Hill or Markham that is simply the house or condo they were living in together. Whose name appears on title does not determine whether the property is a matrimonial home.
It is also possible to have more than one. A cottage or a second property that the family ordinarily used as a residence can qualify as well. Whether a particular property meets the definition depends on the facts, and it is a question worth putting to a family lawyer rather than assuming.
This is the point that surprises people most. A home registered in one spouse's name alone can still be a matrimonial home, with the rights that come with that status extending to the other spouse. Being the only person on title does not give you unilateral control over the property. If you have been operating on the assumption that it does, that is worth clarifying with a lawyer early.
Why It Is Treated Differently
Three protections that apply to married spouses. Tap each to expand.
ProtectionBoth Spouses Have an Equal Right to Stay TAP TO OPEN ▾
Married spouses generally have an equal right to possession of the matrimonial home, whether or not they are on title. Practically, that means neither spouse can simply require the other to move out. Changing the locks or attempting to exclude the other person is not something one spouse can do on their own authority. Where one spouse is to have exclusive possession, that is typically arranged either by agreement between the parties or by a court order.
ProtectionNeither Can Sell or Mortgage It Alone TAP TO OPEN ▾
A matrimonial home generally cannot be sold, mortgaged or otherwise encumbered by one spouse without the other's consent or a court order, again regardless of title. This is why, in practice, listing the home for sale requires both spouses to agree and to sign the listing documents. It also means neither person can quietly refinance or place a new charge against the property during a separation. Lawyers on both sides will look for this consent as a matter of course.
ProtectionIt Is Counted Differently in the Property Division TAP TO OPEN ▾
Ontario's property division rules generally let spouses deduct the value of assets they brought into the marriage. The matrimonial home is treated as an exception to that ordinary treatment. A spouse who owned the home before the marriage, and where it remains the matrimonial home at separation, may not be able to deduct its value the way they could with other property. The financial consequences can be significant, and the rules have nuances and exceptions, so this is very much a question for a family lawyer rather than a general guide.
Married and Common-Law Are Not the Same
The matrimonial home protections described above apply to married spouses. Common-law partners in Ontario are treated differently, and the special matrimonial home status does not apply to them in the same way. A common-law partner who is not on title does not automatically gain the same possession and consent rights over the property.
That does not mean a common-law partner has no possible claim. Claims can arise in other ways, for example based on contributions to the property, but they operate on entirely different legal footing and are far from automatic. If you are separating from a common-law partner, do not rely on anything you have read about matrimonial homes. Get advice specific to your circumstances.
Your Three Main Options
Tap each to expand.
Option 1Sell the Home and Divide the Proceeds TAP TO OPEN ▾
The most common route. The home is listed, sold on the open market and the net proceeds are divided according to the separation agreement or court order. This provides a clean break, converts the largest asset into cash both people can use to move forward and removes the ongoing question of who carries the property.
It requires both spouses to agree on listing, pricing and accepting an offer, which is why having the terms set out in writing in advance saves a great deal of friction later. It also means neither person keeps the home, which can be difficult where children are settled in a school or a neighbourhood.
Option 2One Spouse Buys Out the Other TAP TO OPEN ▾
One spouse keeps the home and compensates the other for their share of its value. This keeps children in a familiar home and neighbourhood, which is often the deciding factor. Two things have to line up for it to work: an agreed value for the property, and the buying spouse qualifying on their own for a mortgage large enough to refinance and fund the buyout.
That second point is where buyouts most often stall, since a household income that comfortably supported the mortgage may not do so on one income. Speak to a lender or mortgage professional early to find out what is actually achievable before building a plan around it.
Option 3Defer the Sale to a Later Date TAP TO OPEN ▾
Some couples agree that one spouse and the children will remain in the home for a defined period, with the property to be sold at an agreed future point, such as when the youngest child finishes school. This provides stability for children during a difficult time. It also keeps two people financially connected to one asset for years, so the agreement needs to spell out clearly who pays the mortgage, taxes, insurance and repairs, how the eventual sale will be handled and how the proceeds will be divided at that time. Deferred arrangements work when the documentation is thorough and cause problems when it is vague.
If You Decide to Sell
Because both spouses generally must consent to a sale, the smoothest listings are the ones where the decisions have been agreed and documented before the sign goes up. That includes the list price, the minimum acceptable offer, who pays for preparation and staging, how showings will be handled and how the proceeds will be split at closing. When these are settled in advance, the sale becomes a straightforward transaction instead of a series of negotiations.
Your lawyers will typically want the arrangement reflected in a separation agreement or court order. Once the home sells, the proceeds are usually held in trust and distributed according to that document. Our closing day guide explains how the money moves on closing, and our commission guide covers what comes off the top.
Selling during a separation often means the home is still lived in, sometimes by both people, sometimes by one. Practical preparation still matters: decluttering, minor repairs, professional photography and easy showing access all affect the price the home achieves, and both spouses benefit equally from a strong sale. Agreeing on a simple showing routine in advance keeps this from becoming another point of friction. Our staging guide covers preparation room by room.
Working With an Agent While Separating
When an agent is representing both spouses on the sale of a matrimonial home, both are the client and both are entitled to the same information at the same time. In practice that means copying both people on everything, presenting every offer to both, scheduling showings around both households and staying out of the personal dispute entirely. An agent's job here is to get the best result on the property, not to take a side.
Some separating couples prefer each to have their own agent or to have their lawyers communicate on their behalf. Any of these arrangements can work. What matters is that expectations about communication are set clearly at the start, so nobody feels they are learning things second-hand during an already difficult period.
Getting the Right Support
A family lawyer is the essential first call. They will advise on your rights regarding the home, the property division and what any agreement should contain. A mediator can help couples reach agreement without litigation, which is usually faster and less costly. A mortgage professional will tell you what a buyout would realistically require. An accountant can flag any tax considerations. A real estate professional handles the valuation, preparation and sale of the property itself.
Separation is genuinely hard, and the decisions about a home get made during one of the more stressful periods in a person's life. If you are finding it overwhelming, speaking with a counsellor or therapist alongside the legal and financial advisors is a reasonable and common thing to do.
Recognition
Kirby Chan Awards and Achievements
🏆 #1 Individual Producer in Ontario for eXp Realty 2023
🏆 Top 3 Best Rated Real Estate Agent in Richmond Hill
🏆 Toronto Star Platinum Award for Best Real Estate Agent
🏆 Top Real Estate Agent Award in Markham
🏆 2X ICON Agent Award with eXp Realty
🏆 2025 Community Votes Platinum Award, Thornhill
🏆 2024 Community Votes Platinum Award, Thornhill
🏆 2025 Gold Award for Real Estate Brokers in Markham
🏆 2024 Community Votes Bronze Award, Richmond Hill
🏆 2023 Community Votes Platinum Award, Thornhill
Frequently Asked Questions
Tap a question to expand the answer.
Can I sell the house if my name is the only one on title?
Generally not on your own, if it is a matrimonial home and you are married. Ontario law typically requires the other spouse's consent or a court order to sell or mortgage a matrimonial home, regardless of whose name is on title. Speak with a family lawyer about your situation.
Can one spouse make the other move out?
Married spouses generally have an equal right to possession of the matrimonial home, so neither can simply require the other to leave. Exclusive possession is normally arranged by agreement between the parties or by a court order.
Do common-law partners have matrimonial home rights in Ontario?
The special matrimonial home protections apply to married spouses and do not extend to common-law partners in the same way. Other types of claims may be possible but operate on different legal footing, so get advice specific to your circumstances.
What are the options for the family home in a separation?
Generally three: sell and divide the proceeds, have one spouse buy out the other, or defer the sale to an agreed future date. Which works depends on finances, whether one spouse can qualify for a mortgage alone and what is best for any children.
Do both spouses need to sign the listing agreement?
In practice, yes, for a matrimonial home where both spouses' consent is required to sell. This is why agreeing on price, terms and process before listing makes the sale far smoother for everyone involved.
Who can help with selling a family home in Richmond Hill or Markham?
Kirby Chan and the Kirby Chan & Co. Real Estate Team handle the valuation, preparation and sale of the property, working alongside your lawyers and keeping communication even-handed with both parties. Reach me at (416) 305-8008.
Need to Sell a Family Home in Richmond Hill or Markham?
When a separation means selling the home, the property side should be the straightforward part. I handle the valuation, the preparation and the sale, work alongside both lawyers and keep communication clear and even-handed with both parties so the transaction does not add to an already difficult situation.
Book a consultation with me for a discreet conversation about the property and a market evaluation.
Kirby Chan | Kirby Chan & Co. Real Estate Team
416-305-8008
kirby@kirbychanandco.com
https://kirbychanandco.com
Note: This guide describes general principles of Ontario family law relating to the matrimonial home in simplified terms. The law contains exceptions, nuances and requirements that are not covered here, outcomes depend heavily on the facts of each case, and legislation and its interpretation change over time. Nothing in this guide is legal, tax or financial advice, and it must not be relied on as a substitute for professional advice. Consult a family lawyer about your rights and obligations before making any decision about a matrimonial home or signing any agreement.
Categories
Recent Posts










